By tomorrow, clubs must complete additions to the 40-man roster to protect eligible players from the rule 5 draft. Generally, anyone signed during or before the 2022 season is eligible, as are those 18 or younger signed during the 2023 season.
Last week, Texas added RHP Aidan Curry to the 40, preventing his impending free agency. Teams passed over Curry in the truncated 2020 draft, but he skipped a Bucknell commitment to sign with Texas as a free agent. Superficially, he’s a bizarre selection, essentially off the national radar since ’24, needing a full six years to reach AA and posting a 5.82 ERA at that level in his walk year. I’d written of him favorably several times this season, however, more than once suggesting the possibility of him being added. (To be clear, I’m not alone in covering Curry post-2024. Fangraphs’ Brendan Gawlowski and Friend Of The Report and Baseball Prospectus contributor Grant Schiller mentioned his ascent during the second half of this season, and local scribe Jamey Newberg never lost hope, placing him 26th entering 2026.)
In most nationally oriented publications, Curry appeared on prospect lists just once, prior to 2024, and promptly vanished after a dismal showing in high-A. 2025 included a shutdown/reboot in rookie ball, but he slowly and fitfully regained form, building a deeper arsenal and occasionally looking like someone who might shine, not just squeak by, at the Major League level. Sometimes, he still reminds of the 2024 version.
Does all this mean I think he’s likely to make it, and do I know in what role? No and no. I don’t even think he’s a slam-dunk selection. But is he a justifiable decision and worthy of more time in the system given his upside and the relative lack of competition for 40-man spots among fellow prospects? Sure.
Best as I can tell, the Rangers have around 40 other eligible players. I wouldn’t be surprised if they protect none. I’d be very surprised if they protect more than one. The possibility of a lockout eliminating the draft this offseason doesn’t color my opinions.
The “one” is RHP Wilian Bormie, who I’d thought was already eligible for free agency, as his listed signing date is December 2019, but he didn’t appear amidst the slew of free-agent announcements last week.
Bormie’s AAA Statcast summary has a gallon of pretty red ink. He throws hard, opponents struggle to make contact and don’t square up when they do. Bormie threw 569 pitches in AAA, 56 (10%) of which were misses on sliders alone. He also generated a huge number of called strikes with it. His ERA in AAA was 2.79 with 32 strikeouts in 29 innings.
Alas, the fastball. 143 Pacific Coast League pitchers threw at least 200 four-seam fastballs last year. Bormie had the worst in-zone rate (37%), the worst strike rate (44%) and the lowest swing rate (30%). Like Emiliano Teodo, Bormie had to rely heavily on the slider to strand the runners placed aboard with his erratic fastball. His BB+HBP rate in Frisco was a career-best 11% but jumped to 17% at Round Rock.
In the full-season minors, the combined walk and hit-batter rate is 27% higher than in 2019. The increase over the same period in the Majors is just 6%. While there are individual exceptions, generally the high-walk pitchers who can strand all those excess runners with strikeouts and weaker contact in the minors either aren’t reaching the Majors or aren’t hanging around long. Bormie hopefully will continue to improve, but as it stands, it’s very hard to envision him succeeding at the MLB level. His type of player is increasingly common. Heck, the Rangers themselves have similar pitchers in the form of Teodo and Collyer.
I feel he’s a player who in the 2010s I would’ve said had to be protected, but not now, even with ample space on the 40. I’m not saying Texas won’t protect him. I just don’t have a a strong opinion about him in this regard.
I don’t see any other likely additions. OF Hector Osorio (#14 Texas prospect per MLB, #16 Baseball America) isn’t ready, and RHP Izack Tiger (#26 MLB and BA) suffered an injury just 27 innings into his return from elbow surgery. I feel my annual rundown of a dozen-or-so potential additions would be overly repetitive this year, so If Texas protects someone I’ve ignored in this post, I’ll offer my thoughts down the road.
Arbitration / Tenders
I covered arbitration-eligibles in last month’s “Choosing A Path” piece. Texas has a tricky decision on catcher O’Hoppe, but I expect the others to receive offers. As for pre-arbs, Texas might decide to jettison a reliever or three, but equally likely is tendering everyone and then attempting to slip individuals through waivers as the situation demands.
Incoming
Texas acquired 23-year-old RHP Juan Arnaud from the Mets for international slot money. Arnaud touched 100 with both a four and two-seamer in 2026 and fanned 74 in 51.2 innings (31% rate) for high-A Brooklyn. He also walked or hit 45 (19%). Arnaud has received honorable mentions in Fangraphs’ annual rankings but has never appeared in any publication’s top 30 as best as I can tell. He’ll be eligible for the Rule 5 draft if unprotected, which is my expectation.
Texas also claimed RHP Jose Butto from the Giants off waivers. Butto barely pitched in 2026. Removed from a messy April outing in which his fastball velocity dipped from the mid to low 90s, Butto hit the DL with “arm fatigue” later diagnosed as a blood clot in his arm that required surgery. Butto reached arbitration eligibility while injured but is projected for a salary of only $800,000 per MLB Trade Rumors, so monetarily he’s essentially a pre-arb player. A pure non-tender would be odd, but Texas might have the intention of a non-tender and immediate re-sign to a respectable minor deal. When healthy, Butto offers a mid-80s slider and a fair number of upper-80s changes in addition to the fastballs. His control is subpar, his effectiveness often dependent on the fickle BABIP gods.
Callback
In cased you missed it, three weeks ago I wrote at length about where Texas stands following the 2026 season and three potential paths forward: more-or-less staying the course, going for broke, or tearing down and rebuilding.
Up Next
I’ve already written “where are they now” summaries of everyone Texas has traded since the beginning of last season. I’ll post it soon. I’ll also have an Arizona Fall League review.